Ice Cream & Candy Bazaar

You'll find a sweet escape at Ice Cream & Candy Bazaar, a charming waterfront confectionery tucked along Edgartown harbor. Step inside and you're greeted by 32 flavors of freshly scooped ice cream, bins of penny candy, house-made fudge, rich chocolates, and old-fashioned licorice — the kind of place that turns a quick stop into a lingering afternoon. The shop carries a wonderfully unhurried, classic-island feel with wheelchair-accessible seating right near the water. It's the sort of spot locals swear by and visitors stumble onto with delight — a family-friendly, no-frills gem that earns its 4.7-star reputation one scoop at a time. Whether you're loading up on nostalgic penny candy or going all-in on a double scoop, the Candy Bazaar delivers pure, simple joy with every visit.