food-drink in Tisbury (Vineyard Haven)

Mad Martha's Ice Cream

You'll taste island history at Mad Martha's Ice Cream, a Martha's Vineyard institution since 1971 — famously launched out of the back of an ambulance sedan by a farm girl who accidentally froze her cream supply and turned the mishap into something magical. All ice cream is made fresh daily in-house, and you'll taste the difference in every scoop. The Vineyard Haven location on Union Street is their newest home, offering the same beloved flavors that locals and summer visitors have lined up for across generations. Don't miss the mint chocolate chip, black raspberry, or the inspired Back Door Donuts apple fritter collab. With locations also in Oak Bluffs and Edgartown, Mad Martha's is the quintessential Vineyard summer ritual — the kind of cone you plan your afternoon around.

24 Union St, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568

The Black Dog Pub

You'll find yourself stepping back into Martha's Vineyard history the moment you walk through the doors of The Black Dog Tavern — the island's most iconic restaurant, perched on the edge of Vineyard Haven Harbor since 1971. This beloved waterfront landmark serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner with unmatched harbor views from its rustic, wood-beamed dining room and open patio. The menu leans into New England classics: fresh local seafood, chef-crafted entrées, homemade desserts, and a full bar. On summer Friday evenings, live music drifts across the water. Whether you're grabbing breakfast before the ferry or lingering over dinner at sunset, the Tavern delivers that rare combination of casual warmth and genuine Cape and Islands tradition that keeps visitors coming back year after year.

20 Beach Street Ext, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568