Every place we've verified, town by town.

Beetlebung Farm

MakersChilmark

Beetlebung Farm is a historic market garden of more than six acres in the heart of Chilmark town center on Martha's Vineyard. Four generations of the Fischer family farmed the land from 1961 through 2018, and its current stewards are turning it into a four-season regenerative farm. The fields grow vegetables, herbs, flowers and berries, with fruit trees, a small apiary and a young food forest. A nineteenth-century barn holds the year-round farmstand, a kitchen whose grab-and-go menu changes day to day with the harvest, and a stone mill and bakery making slow-fermented sourdough from freshly milled Northeast grain. The farmstand is open Wednesday through Sunday, 8am to 5:30pm. Cape Cod Certified visited and photographed Beetlebung Farm in person.

C.B. Stark Jewelers

MakersEdgartown

C.B. Stark Jewelers is a Martha's Vineyard jewelry maker with a seasonal shop at 10 Main Street in Edgartown and a year-round store in Vineyard Haven. Its story began in the summer of 1966, when Cheryl Barbara Stark took the ferry to the island to teach jewelry making. Cheryl and her partner Margie Meltzer grew it from a twelve-foot-square garage into a full-service jeweler. They have created more than five hundred original island designs in gold, silver, and platinum, including grape clusters, the Vineyard silhouette, town signs, and the Gingerbread Collection inspired by the Oak Bluffs Camp Ground cottages. The shops also offer repair, engraving, and custom design. Cape Cod Certified visited and photographed C.B. Stark in person.

Cabot's Candy

MakersProvincetown

Cabot's Candy has been "A Sweet Tradition Since 1927" — Provincetown's family-run home of handmade saltwater taffy, pulled in flavors from banana to creamsicle to sea salt caramel. Grab a bucket of assorted taffy, a slab of Copper Kettle Fudge, or a bag of Cabot's Best Brittle on your way down Commercial Street.

Isabel Souza Studio

MakersWellfleet

Isabel Souza Studio is a local artist's pottery studio and shop. You find it down a short flight of steps at 313 Main Street, under a round black sign with a sunburst logo. Inside are her own ceramic designs alongside jewelry, art, textiles and accessories. It's a small, personal stop on the Main Street walk for something handmade to bring home.

Masterson Made

MakersWoods Hole

Masterson Made is a thoughtfully curated home decor, art, and gift shop in Woods Hole village, Falmouth. Owners Melissa and Patrick create woodwork on-site — handcrafted cutting boards and soy candles — alongside a carefully selected collection of coastal kitchenware, original artwork, and locally made goods. It's the kind of store where everything on the shelf has a story.

Newcomb Hollow Shop

MakersWellfleet

Newcomb Hollow Shop is the white house with the red door and red window boxes at 275 Main Street, with wicker chairs set out on the front patio. The shop bills itself as handmade Cape Cod: locally made pottery, lamps, planters, birdhouses and earrings and necklaces. You'll also find soft pashminas, kids' lamps and craft chocolate. It's a good place to find a coastal gift or something for the house that wasn't made far away.

Soul Gems by Maria

MakersEdgartown

Soul Gems by Maria is a fine jewelry boutique at 7 Winter Street in Edgartown on Martha's Vineyard, just steps from the harbor. Founder Maria Elmore Harleston launched it in 2022 and hand-selects every piece herself. The collection is new and vintage 14- and 18-karat gold jewelry and gemstones: more than a thousand unique pieces, no two alike. Every visit starts with a conversation, and Maria helps with layering and styling. Private and virtual appointments are available too. The boutique is open Monday through Saturday from 10am to 7pm, and Sunday from 10am to 4pm. Cape Cod Certified visited and photographed Soul Gems by Maria in person.

Starke Art Designs

MakersMashpee

Starke Art Designs is a needlepoint design studio a few doors down from The Chocolate Rose in the Otis Landing plaza in Mashpee. The studio designs hand-painted needlepoint canvases and teaches classes in finishing your own pieces (ornaments, bag charms, stand-ups), painting needlepoint canvases, and needlefelting. Out front, the covered walkway is hung with twisted-vine arches and wreaths, and a vine table shows resin art pieces with pressed flowers.

Tesori

MakersEdgartown

Tesori is a fine jewelry and gift shop at 8 Dock Street in Edgartown, on Martha's Vineyard. It carries designer jewelry, fine fragrances, beauty products and exclusive pieces for the home. The cases hold work from a long list of designers, including Julie Vos and Freida Rothman. Fragrance and beauty lines include Ligne St Barth and Kevyn Aucoin. New arrivals are posted on Instagram, and you can call to make an appointment. Tesori shares the site with The Great Put On, where you can shop clothing. Cape Cod Certified visited and photographed Tesori in person.

The Spice and Tea Exchange

MakersMashpee

Tucked into Mashpee Commons near Williams Sonoma, this is the only Spice & Tea Exchange in Massachusetts, and it hand-mixes seasonings on-site daily. Explore over 120 fresh spices, 85-plus handcrafted blends, 24 world salts, naturally flavored sugars, and more than 30 gourmet teas, then linger at the tea bar over a hot or iced cup. A fragrant Mashpee destination for cooks, gift-givers, and anyone chasing serious flavor.

Tumbleweed Quilts & Fabrics

MakersSandwich

A fabric-lover's paradise in Sandwich, this welcoming quilt shop stocks an extensive, color-rich selection of quilting cottons, Tilda Fabrics, books, patterns, and notions, plus the largest selection of English Paper Piecing papers around. Knowledgeable staff happily help you find the perfect fabric and guide every skill level through sewing and quilting classes. A creative haven of fabrics, supplies, and hands-on workshops for quilters and crafters across Cape Cod.

Whatever Sterling Silver

MakersEdgartown

Whatever Sterling Silver is a jewelry shop at 1 Main Street in Edgartown, on Martha's Vineyard. The owners design their own pieces and travel the world to find unique, one-of-a-kind jewelry, so the cases are worth a slow look. Cape Cod Certified visited and photographed Whatever Sterling Silver in person.